The best underdog stories in Premier League history

With its global audience and reputation for high-stakes drama, the Premier League has seen its fair share of David vs. Goliath narratives, where the underdogs have defied the odds to create moments of footballing magic. These stories enrich the league’s history and inspire fans and teams worldwide. 

Here are some of the most memorable underdog stories in Premier League history. They showcase the sport’s unpredictable nature and the indomitable spirit of those who dared to dream.

Sheffield United’s Historic Win Over Manchester United (1992)

On the inaugural day of the Premier League, Sheffield United not only claimed a victory against the formidable Manchester United but also etched their name in history by securing the first-ever Premier League underdog victory. 

Under Dave Bassett’s management, the Blades showcased a stunning performance against Alex Ferguson’s side. Brian Deane’s header from a long throw-in marked the first goal of the new league, giving Sheffield United the lead. 

After Alan Cork was fouled, Deane doubled their advantage from the penalty spot. Despite a goal from Mark Hughes, assisted by Peter Schmeichel, Sheffield United held on to win, marking a memorable start to the Premier League era.

Leicester City’s Fairy Tale Season (2015-2016)

Perhaps the most extraordinary underdog story in football history, Leicester City’s title win in the 2015-2016 season stands as a testament to what can be achieved through teamwork, perseverance, and a bit of magic. 

The Foxes, led by Claudio Ranieri and with standout performances from Jamie Vardy and Riyad Mahrez, clinched the Premier League title against 5000-1 odds. The triumph spurred enthusiasm among betting enthusiasts, many of whom had not foreseen Leicester City’s ascension. 

In light of this historic win, sportsbooks have since adjusted their strategies, now offering odds for this season that reflect a heightened consideration for potential underdog victories. In this environment of renewed optimism for the underdog, fans also explore new opportunities to enhance their betting experiences. Many are turning to top platforms, where promotions like the bet365 bonus code offer newcomers a chance to claim a welcome bonus, providing an additional edge in their wagering efforts.

Sunderland’s Shocking Wins Against Chelsea and Manchester City

Sunderland has contributed to some of the most surprising results in Premier League history. In 2010, they handed Chelsea, the reigning champions, a 3-0 defeat, showcasing a lively attack that the Blues could not counter. 

Another memorable moment came in 2012 when they beat Manchester City 1-0 thanks to a goal in the match’s dying moments. These victories underscore the unpredictable nature of football, where the underdog can emerge triumphant​ on any given day.

Arsenal’s Surprise Defeat to Norwich City (1992)

The same day Sheffield made history, Norwich City staged an incredible comeback at Highbury against Arsenal. 

The Gunners, boasting a two-nil lead by the 40th minute with goals from Steve Bould and Kevin Campbell, seemed to be cruising to victory. However, Norwich City, inspired by a Mark Robins brace alongside contributions from David Phillips and Ruel Fox, overturned the deficit in the second half. 

The remarkable comeback earned Norwich City an unforgettable win and delayed Arsenal’s first points in the Premier League.

Sunderland Stuns Chelsea (2010)

In 2010, Sunderland, under Steve Bruce, faced Chelsea, a team that had been exhibiting dominating performances under Carlo Ancelotti. Chelsea, the reigning league champions, had an impressive start to the season and a formidable goal difference. However, Sunderland defied expectations with a vibrant attack led by Nedum Onuoha, Asamoah Gyan, and Danny Welbeck. 

Onuoha’s solo goal was followed by Gyan’s finish and a mistake from Ashley Cole, which Welbeck capitalized on, culminating in a 3-0 victory for Sunderland. This win is remembered as a testament to Sunderland’s tenacity and tactical brilliance.

Aston Villa’s Remarkable Win Over Liverpool (2020)

Aston Villa delivered a stunning performance by defeating the reigning champions Liverpool with a scoreline of 7-2. The match showcased Villa’s attacking prowess and highlighted the Premier League’s competitive and unpredictable nature. It also demonstrated that even the mightiest teams could be vulnerable, providing hope and encouragement to underdogs everywhere​.

Norwich City Overpowers Manchester City (2019)

Having recently been promoted in September 2019, Norwich City welcomed Pep Guardiola’s Manchester City to Carrow Road. The visitors were favorites, given their unbeaten league run since January of the same year. However, Norwich City took full advantage of Manchester City’s defensive disarray, with Kenny McLean and Todd Cantwell giving the Canaries an early lead. 

Despite Sergio Agüero pulling one back for City, Teemu Pukki’s goal extended Norwich’s lead. A late goal from Rodri was not enough for City, as Norwich secured a sensational 3-2 victory, demonstrating that determination and strategic play could triumph over pedigree.

Final Thoughts

These underdog stories show the teams’ competitive spirit but also as an inspiration. It encapsulates the essence of why football, particularly the Premier League, holds such a special place in the hearts of millions around the globe. 

The legacy of these underdog triumphs continues to inspire, reminding us why we cherish this game so deeply.

Learn about football betting for FREE

Join our free email course to learn all about football betting. You will learn theory and techniques to make you a better bettor!

Sign up for free