I was dubious when Brisbane Roar appointed Robbie Fowler as their manager last season. However, the Englishman did a sterling job, getting the best out of a seriously limited team, making them very competitive and organised. Since he left though, which was due to the Covid-19 situation, Brisbane Roar have started to show more of their true level. When they play a compact style, they can be hard to score against. Their goal threat is easily the most limited in the A-League though, and nothing they’ve done pre-season has changed my opinion on that front.
Let’s look at who they’ve lost first, shall we? Star goalkeeper Crocombe has gone, signing for Melbourne Victory. I’m not too concerned on that front because Jamie Young is a good enough shot stopper at this level nowadays. Midfield engines Ridenton, McGing, and O’Neill all moved on, which will make them less competitive and mobile in the centre of the pitch. Experienced defenders Neville and Bowles have both elft, although it could be argued that the latter is a blessing in disguise, given his penchant for clumsy challenges and cards. The big ones to leave, however, were Inman and Amadi-Holloway. Inman was their main driving force between midfield and attack, scoring a fair number of goals. Amadi-Holloway was a dreadful finisher but his ability in the air and his work-rate made him incredibly difficult to play against. Losing all of these players at once is a big, big risk for Brisbane Roar.
Yes, they’ve brought some players in but nowhere near as many as they’ve lost. Indeed, their more significant signings have been in the final third where Champness joins from Newcastle Jets, and their Japanese duo, Danzaki and Kudo, join with the intent of providing Brisbane Roar with more natural flair and cute passing in the final third. I like Champness, for what it’s worth. He did a good job at Newcastle Jets before taking a year out to pursue a music career. I think he can be a success at an A-League club but he does need support, and I am not sure Brisbane Roar can give it to him.
They’ve still got defensive stability in Gillesphey and Aldred, a set piece specialist in O’Shea, and a brilliant striker in veteran McDonald. I can’t doubt the work-rate of Brisbane Roar, and if they play defensively, they will contain a number of their opponents, for the most part. However, I have very real concerns about their ability to get to their opponents’ goal. I don’t see enough of a wide threat, and there aren’t enough midfielders capable of turning their man and making an incisive, well-weighted pass. Unless their Japanese duo fill that role well, I can see McDonald and/or Champness being a bit too isolated up top, and that’s not ideal. That, fused with the club’s decision to play its home games this season at the Dolphin Stadium in Redcliffe (with mixed response from their fans), makes me think they’re not in an ideal position to kick this season off.
Melbourne City look a bit more settled, to me. I’m not blown away by the idea of Kisnorbo leading this team but I’ll reserve judgement on that front. I still think that they’ve got one of the most well-balanced squads in the A-League, and they’ve only added to it pre-season. For example, I was concerned that losing Brillante would mean they had no midfield terrier, and a team that doesn’t generally press its opponents needs someone like that. However, they’ve added O’Neill so it’s problem solved as far as I am concerned. Experienced full-back Garuccio is a good signing too; very consistent at both ends of the pitch. I’m not Nabbout’s biggest fan but I recognise the potential of him playing alongside MacLaren; they’ll be lethal on the break together.
They’ve barely lost anyone either, Melbourne City. I mentioned Brillante, who has been replaced. Wales was fast but ineffectual; Nabbout is a better alternative. Susaeta left to join Macarthur FC, and as good as he is, I never really felt he was on the same wavelength as his teammates. The rest are just kids, and most of them are only on loan. Dukuly impressed recently for Adelaide United but Melbourne City aren’t as big on playing their talented youngsters as they could or should be otherwise Colakovski would have seen more game time by now. So, yeah – no major changes at Melbourne City this season. Whether they’ve got the mental strength to actually challenge for the title remains to be seen, though.
The quality in this squad is undeniable. MacLaren is arguably the best striker in the division, especially with Sydney FC’s Le Fondre having left to play in India. Noone and Luna support him well, as will Nabbout, and that’s a foursome that don’t require a great deal of support to be effective, which will no doubt appeal to Melbourne City’s desire to play defensive football. In Griffiths, Good, Jamieson, Metcalfe etc. they have a good defensive setup. My only real curiosity this season is the whereabouts of Harrison Delbridge. He was a superb centre-back for them two years ago, had a very ropey campaign last time around, and has now seemingly disappeared. Melbourne City can cope without him but it’s just a bit strange is all.
I don’t expect Melbourne City to be great entertainers because they’re not. However, I do think that they’re setup rather well to be the counterattacking team that they’ve longed to be for years, finally having more than just one attacking threat. I don’t see them giving many goals away, and they should be well-placed to take their chances with MacLaren up front. Therefore, I expect them to do reasonably well this season, and they really should be able to kick things off with a win in Brisbane today.